Gender Politix: He or She?
So what do you call someone who is a transsexual- he or she? The nicest solution would seem to be to call the person whatever they say they are- if they want to be a she, call them a she. However, there’s an obvious flaw in that. What if someone says they are the king of Antarctica, am I supposed to call them Your Majesty? Which wishful delusions are we supposed to support and which not? Niceness conflicts with accuracy. A man wearing lipstick and a skirt is not a woman. A man wearing lipstick and a skirt and announcing that he is a woman is still not a woman. It is not the idea of gender-reassignment I have a problem with, just the feeling that I am being forced to use inaccurate terms. I saw a show recently in which a young person was surgically altered from male to female, and all the people around him forced the word “she” into the conversation every which way possible- She’s a big girl, she’ll do well in surgery, won’t she? It sounded to me like an attempt to say something so often that people start to believe it- propaganda, in other words.
But then again, if a man in a skirt is a man, what’s a man in a skirt with implanted breasts, no penis or testicles, and a surgically sculpted vulva?
A common genderless pronoun would help- as you can see I improperly but effectively used “they” at the beginning of the post- but it really only hides the problem. And I reject the idea that gender is a societal construct that doesn’t really exist and therefore needs no words to describe it- yes there are people born with chromosomes mixed up in such a way that they are neither male nor female; this no more invalidates the other 6 billion people’s gender than people who’s mixed up chromosomes result in them having no arms invalidates the concept of arms.
But then again, if a man in a skirt is a man, what’s a man in a skirt with implanted breasts, no penis or testicles, and a surgically sculpted vulva?
A common genderless pronoun would help- as you can see I improperly but effectively used “they” at the beginning of the post- but it really only hides the problem. And I reject the idea that gender is a societal construct that doesn’t really exist and therefore needs no words to describe it- yes there are people born with chromosomes mixed up in such a way that they are neither male nor female; this no more invalidates the other 6 billion people’s gender than people who’s mixed up chromosomes result in them having no arms invalidates the concept of arms.

3 Comments:
You're tackling some heavy shit now, Dawg. You might imagine the difficulty in dealing with this "issue" on campus - housing issues, public bathroom issues, political correctness issues... Once again, though, you manage to come up with one quote pretty much every day that just kills me - "this no more invalidates the other 6 billion people’s gender than people who’s mixed up chromosomes result in them having no arms invalidates the concept of arms". Who but you would even consider the idea of invalidating the concept of arms? Classic, man. Fuckin' classic.
Dear DoorHinge,
I have a penis unique and powerful. I can actually use it to impregnate men. What is my gender?
Those guys are lying to you.
Post a Comment
<< Home